Reviewed by Macy A.
ONE DAY IN DECEMBER
By Josie Silver
416 pages. Broadway Books.
What do you do when you spot The One, fall irrevocably in love in the span of 60 seconds, lose them right after, spend the next year searching for them in every bus stop in London, then finally meet them again when they’re introduced as your best friend’s new boyfriend? Thus begins “One Day in December” and the love story of Laurie and Jack, spanning ten years of heartbreak, choosing to be happy, loss, what-might-have-beens, and finding happiness again.
Laurie James meets, or doesn’t meet, Jack O’Mara at the bus stop on December 21, 2008. She’s on an overcrowded bus, on the way home from a long shift at a hotel reception desk – a job she’s working while she’s trying to get a job as a staff writer at a magazine. She looks out the window and sees the most beautiful man sitting at the bus stop. He looks up, their eyes meet, and something shifts in the universe. But as fate would have it, Laurie’s bus pulls away just as Jack gets up. Laurie spends a year looking for “Bus Boy” throughout London, roping in her best friend Sarah to help with the search. She doesn’t find him, not until that fateful day when Sarah introduces the new boyfriend that she’s head-over-heels for. “Bus Boy” is Jack, Sarah’s boyfriend.
Romance novels live and die by their characters, and “One Day” passes with flying colors. Laurie and Jack are fully formed and relatable: good people who genuinely care for each other and the people around them but are deeply flawed as well. The story is told from Laurie and Jack’s alternating point of views, which gives us a lot of insight into their motivations. The downside of this is that Sarah’s characterization gets lost in the shuffle. As Laurie’s BFF and Jack’s girlfriend, Sarah becomes the ultimate example of virtue and success, and any flaws she has is told to us, not shown.
The story also benefits from the longer timespan. The ten years it takes for Laurie and Jack to finally be together are caused by both circumstances and their personal choices, which makes their journey all the better for it. There’s some pining to be sure, but neither one fully depends on the other for their personal growth. Josie Silver handles their will they-won’t they with a deft hand, making sure that there are no irredeemable bad guys.
One frustration of mine with regards to romance novels is when the characters are at the mercy of the plot, where they have no agency and every roadblock to their happily ever after is an external force. I’m happy that it wasn’t the case here.
My only major regret is that the resolution happens so quickly. Laurie and Jack were separated for so long. Surely Ms. Silver could have devoted more page time to their happily ever after? As someone who got sucked into this story, I would have appreciated a longer and more substantial final act.
All in all, “One Day in December” is highly recommended for believers in love at first sight. And even if you don’t, it’s still recommended for its depiction of supportive female friendships and the importance of finding your own happiness and way in life even without The One.
One Day in December by Josie Silver is available at Fully Booked branches and Fully Booked Online.
Macy Añonuevo is a sustainability professional, writer, marine science nerd, and geek who loves to eat, travel, talk about science, and take pictures of stuff. She also has way too many books in her to-read pile, and is afraid she’ll never read them all. You can find her at www.theislandergirl.com and on Instagram @theislandergirl.
[Thoughts and views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Fully Booked. Then again, we love our authors anyway.]